top of page

Welcome To Misfit Toys Rescue Division!


Misfit Toys Rescue Division, Inc


Donate via Paypal, Debit, or Credit Card with the button below.

We thank you for any help!

Welcome to Misfit Toys Rescue Division, Inc's webpage!  Here you will find all of our latest news, horses available for adoption, volunteer information, and a sample of our adoption agreements.  It is our greatest hope to find the perfect match for each of the horses in our care, and we commit to provide a home for life to each horse we take in, no matter the severity of their needs.

Our Mission

We take great pride in the quality care, evaluation, and sanctuary we provide to each horse that we save from auction, killpen, or other dangerous situations.  Our sanctuary is unique in that we specialize in elderly and problem horses, working with them through each issue and fully retraining them until they are ready to find a new vocation that is suitable to their specific needs.    Because of this commitment, we love these horses as if they were our own and promise to take each one back if their placement doesn't work out for any reason.  If a horse becomes fully retrained and cannot find a home for any reason, he gets a job at the rescue either giving lessons, being a camp horse, or being a companion to another new horse.  We find that the prouder a horse is of himself each day, the more he is willing to give and accomplish.  Most of our Misfit Toys will even attend a few horse shows per year!  Come cheer them on as they show the world that they are not just misfits!

Our Story

Our rescue was created to make a difference in the horse world.
We seem to be living in disposable times, and horses are noble beings and friends that are proud to be our partners who deserve to be cared for from birth to death.  It was painful to watch horses be used and then disposed of when owners didn't win enough with them, or didn't give the relationship enough time to grow.  We decided to step in for these horses and make a difference in their lives, teaching them to trust again and assigning them new, more appropriate jobs they could be proud to perform and could be successful doing each day.  By treating the horses with respect and dignity, as well as seeing each one as useful in their own way it allows the horse the first stepping stone to overcoming their fears and becoming a good partner to their new human.
We use a slow, easy retraining method along with veterinary, chiropractic, and proper farrier work to correct any issues our rescues have that may have caused previous roadblocks in life.  Since 2020, our rescue has shifted to a sanctuary only format, meaning that we are no longer actively seeking homes for the horses that remain in our care.  Too many were being returned, and it was causing further trauma to the horses that we had worked so hard with to restore their faith in humans.  They were still, despite our best efforts, continuing to be disappointed in the human race when we would place them in other homes, so we decided to bring them back and they now either give lessons to underprivileged youth in the greater Louisville and Southern Indiana areas or remain retired here in our fields.

Our Facility

Our new and permanent facility is located at the historic Hidden Springs Farm in Palmyra, Indiana. We now have an indoor and outdoor arenas, and utilize a perfect space that is rehab specific and will meet our exact needs, and also accommodates our free riding lesson program for under privileged children in the immediate area due to its close proximity to Louisville, KY. 

Our Director

Our director Danielle Navarro is a second generation horseperson whose father was also committed to bettering the lives of at risk and lower priced horses and retraining them for success in the show ring.  She uses the methodology that there "are no problem horses, only problem riders" to solve most of the horse's problems during the retraining process.  She sees value in each horse and sees them all as completely useful, even if in very creative ways. 


Pictured:  Supreme Temptress, our first rescue, now being shown successfully.

Our Volunteers

Our Horses

We are not breed specific, but specialize in Saddlebreds, Arabians, and Quarter horses, retraining each for jobs in the Saddle Seat, Western, and Reining disciplines.  In addition to horses we save at auctions or killpens, we take in owner surrenders and unwanted horses all year long.  Please contact Danielle for details!

We are always accepting new volunteers to learn the in's and out's of rescue, along with how to refeed, retrain, and properly care for horses and their emotional and physical health.  Please contact us for more details!

Please call us to learn more

1 (502) 424-4987

bottom of page